SNL Season 51 Cast Changes: Heidi Gardner, Michael Longfellow Exit as Lorne Michaels Reshapes the Show

SNL Season 51 cast changes are officially underway, and they’re bigger than a typical August trickle of news. Longtime standout Heidi Gardner is leaving after eight seasons, while Michael Longfellow departs after three, alongside Devon Walker and Emil Wakim. Two writers—Celeste Yim and Rosebud Baker—are also out.

It’s a sweeping reset that creator Lorne Michaels previewed after the show’s 50th-anniversary victory lap, and it sets up a new era for Saturday Night Live as the NBC institution returns on October 4, 2025.

Table of Contents

Who’s Out—and What’s Confirmed

Heidi Gardner exits after eight seasons, closing a run that made her one of SNL’s most versatile utility players—from the “Every Boxer’s Girlfriend” character to breakout Weekend Update desk turns. Multiple outlets reported her departure the same day, underscoring that this is part of a broader, deliberate reshuffle rather than an isolated move.

Michael Longfellow, promoted to repertory in Season 50 and long rumored as a potential Weekend Update successor, also leaves. The exit came despite recent screen tests reportedly exploring a new anchor configuration—another sign that SNL’s post-50 strategy is being reset from the top down.

Devon Walker announced an exit with a candid Instagram note describing his three years as rewarding but sometimes “toxic as hell,” while Emil Wakim shared that he was not asked back after one season. Together, those moves round out four cast departures ahead of the premiere.

Inside the writers’ room, Celeste Yim confirmed departure after five seasons—an especially notable change given Yim’s voice on recent SNL political and cultural sketches—while Rosebud Baker departs as she ramps a touring slate.

Why the Shake-Up Is Happening Now

Michaels telegraphed this turn publicly: the plan was to keep Season 50 intact for the celebration and then “shake things up” ahead of Season 51. He said news would land “in a week or so,” and that’s exactly what happened—wholesale casting and staffing changes condensed into a late-August reveal. The timing aligns with SNL’s standard contracting window and allows a new cohort to integrate during September rehearsals.

Strategically, SNL faces familiar pressures: a fragmented audience, streaming competition, and a political cycle that demands sharper point-of-view. A deliberate recasting can refresh segment chemistry, rebalance sketch-to-desk ratios, and set the stage for new tentpole characters to emerge by Thanksgiving.

Industry watchers have long noted that SNL’s strongest multi-year runs follow periods of concentrated change; this is one of those hinge moments. (NBC’s own Season 51 page frames it as “the start of a new era.”)

Weekend Update: What Happens to the Desk?

Fan chatter has zeroed in on Weekend Update, especially after reports that Longfellow screen-tested for the anchor chair. For now, NBC lists Colin Jost and Michael Che as continuing anchors through Season 50 and defers Season 51 specifics; no official anchor change has been announced.

Given the exits, the simplest read is that Jost and Che return at least to start Season 51 while the show integrates additions elsewhere in the cast. Expect clarity closer to premiere week.

Heidi Gardner’s Legacy—and What’s Next

Gardner’s SNL arc—featured in Season 43, repertory by 45—coincided with transitions from the McKinnon/Bryant/Strong era, and she became a stabilizing presence who could seamlessly toggle from absurdist characters to grounded desk bits. She also delivered viral moments (remember breaking during “Beavis and Butt-Head”).

With exits confirmed, coverage has linked her to more film and prestige TV work; she’s already appeared in Shrinking and Hustle, and that pipeline likely expands now that the weekly grind is paused.

Michael Longfellow: From Update Energy to What’s After SNL

Longfellow’s laconic Update rhythm and understated sketch beats gave SNL a modern, deadpan frequency—especially when political material needed a different temperature. Industry reports say he’d tested for Update this summer, but the reset changed those plans. His next chapter probably leans into stand-up touring and streaming specials, which have become proven springboards for recent SNL alumni.

Devon Walker and Emil Wakim: The Human Side of Turnover

Walker’s open description of the job as both “really cool” and “toxic as hell” struck a chord because it captures the paradox of SNL: it’s a dream role that compresses time, sleep, and ego into one of TV’s most unforgiving deadlines.

Wakim, a one-season player, framed his departure with gratitude but made clear it wasn’t his call. None of this is unusual in SNL cycles, but the transparency surrounding exits is more 2025 than 1975—and it pressures the show to explain (through the work) why each change serves the comedy.

Writers’ Room Changes Matter

Yim’s five-year run coincided with SNL’s push to layer more specific cultural POVs into sketches. Losing that voice—and a road-tested joke engine in Rosebud Baker—means Season 51 will likely elevate newer writers quickly. In SNL history, writer departures often precipitate the emergence of new recurring bits; watch early episodes for which voices the show foregrounds.

Fan Reaction: Grief, Nostalgia, and Optimism

Fans are already mourning the chemistry between Update and recurring Gardner characters, with some urging NBC to bring her back as a future host. Others see opportunity: a chance for fresh repertory players to claim larger sketch real estate and for featured players to break through.

The reaction underscores how SNL functions for viewers—as a weekly relationship, not just a show—and why casting news lands like sports free agency. (Trade coverage and fan forums alike treated this week’s news as a true “shake-up.”)

What to Watch for When Season 51 Premieres

Cold Open Energy: With politics heating up, expect recalibrated impression lineups and possibly new anchor beats that compress headlines more tightly.
New Characters by Halloween: SNL’s lasting additions often arrive by episode 4–5. Track which new or promoted players land recurring personas quickly.
Update Chemistry: If Jost and Che continue, look for different in-desk rhythms or guest-commentator cadence to reflect the new cast makeup.
Host Strategy: The premiere host choice often signals the season’s tone (prestige actor vs. viral musician vs. athletic crossover). NBC hasn’t announced the opener yet.

Bottom Line: A Necessary Reset

Every SNL generation ends the same way: suddenly, then all at once. The SNL Season 51 cast changes feel larger because they touch nearly every corner of the show—repertory, featured, writers—and they follow a celebratory, high-rating 50th season. But within that disruption sits SNL’s enduring advantage: it can rebuild on the fly in front of a live audience.

If the new mix lands fast, you’ll see it in the first month’s ratings, in which sketches go viral, and in the confidence of the midseason episodes. For now, the message is clear: trust the reset, and watch who seizes the moment on October 4.

External link: NBC confirms Season 51 premieres October 4 at 11:30 p.m. ET on NBC and Peacock.

FAQ

When does Season 51 start? October 4, 2025 at 11:30 p.m. ET on NBC/Peacock.

Which cast members have confirmed they’re leaving? Heidi Gardner, Michael Longfellow, Devon Walker, and Emil Wakim.

Which writers are departing? Celeste Yim and Rosebud Baker.

Who’s hosting the premiere? Not announced yet (as of publication).